Dear Holly,
My child is returning to school/starting university soon and needs a new computer for his/her work. What type of computer do you recommend we get them? And what programs should we buy to go with it?
Holly says:
We often get asked to recommend a computer for a new semester, but there are so many options we thought it would be good to give this general “recommedation” in this installment.
Type
The first question we get asked is what type to get. We don’t mean brand, we mean either a desktop computer or a laptop. Lots of people think laptops are the answer as they are mobile but we disagree in most cases. In our experience (even with business users) most “mobile” users are far from it and usually have a laptop on their desk and never move it.
A desktop computer with similar specifications to a laptop is usually a lot cheaper, is less prone to problems (mainly because they can stay a lot cooler than a laptop) and are easier and cheaper to upgrade and remain current.
If you do need a laptop, we would still recommend going for a business class laptop than a “home” user one from the retail stores. This is because the estimated life span of the two are greatly different and so the quality of components are not as good. For example, most laptops look the same black plastic – but the business ones usually have a metal frame inside them to prevent damage when moved. The hard drives and components (and usually the warranty) for a business laptop are designed to last at least 3 years, whereas a home laptop is usually designed to last a year. So although they are more expensive, a business laptop is designed to last a lot longer. A desktop has similar warranties but due to the few times they are moved they tend to last a lot longer (4 – 6 years).
Hardware
The main concerns for the student when it comes to the new computer is speed, storage and screen. Firstly we would like to recommend that you do not buy a computer to play games on. We are great believers for the right tools for the right job. A computer is not for games – XBOX, Playstation etc. are for games and do a great job.
The two main factors affecting speed in a computer is the processor and memory. A dual core processor will be faster than a single core. The more memory the better. Nowadays 2Gb is probably the minimum you would want and 4Gb would be good to last 3 or 4 years. As strange as it may seem 2x 2Gb is faster than 1x 4Gb. This is because they sit on “channel” and so the computer can split the work across two devices at the same time.
When it comes to storage – the more the better. 500Gb, 750Gb disks are relatively inexpensive. You can always add to your storage with more disks, bigger disks or external disks if you want.
System
The biggest question we always get asked is should I get a Mac or a PC? And our normal response for students is sometimes “Neither”. Why? Because there is a little known free system called Ubuntu that often is sufficient for a lot of people. When we ask what the computer will be used for, most say “Email, the internet and school work – documents and presentations”. Ubuntu does all of this built in. It is a Linux based system with Firefox as the web browser and OpenOffice (remember our second installment) for the coursework.
For those who need more than this then it is a choice between a Mac and a Windows PC. They both have pros and cons. Don’t believe all the hype by either side. A Mac will cost you more money for the same thing. A Windows PC will often be harder to use and keep updated (this is the compromise – either let Mac do everything and control everything for you or let it be more open such as Windows, which means you lose control over what people are able to send to you).
A word of warning. A Mac can get a virus. Don’t be fooled by the ads and hype. Although not targeted as much (yet) it can and has had viruses. So please don’t get complacent and think you are safe from all viruses – buy an antivirus for Mac.
The other point to note is you have to have a program specially written for the operating system. So you cannot use normal Microsoft Office on a Mac you have to use the Mac version. This means that not every program has been written to use both systems so it will pay to check if there are any special programs you will need for your coursework before making your choice.
If there are no special programs needed or the programs are available on both systems, and there are no preference from the school or university course then it really is your choice. Go to a store and try both types and see which you prefer. The type and hardware recommendations above apply to both Mac’s and Windows PC’s alike.
Remember, once you have your new computer, you want to keep it updated and working correctly. In which case you may be interested in our HomePak™ or CollegePak™






